Welcome to Waterwitch Neighborhood Grocer & Gourmet, your friendly small-town grocery store with a big selection! We offer everything from fresh conventional and organic produce to a variety of cheeses, gluten-free, and plant-based options. Our shelves are stocked with specialty meats, gourmet pantry items, and delicious daily deliveries of fresh bread and pastries.

Inside, you’ll also find our cozy coffee counter, serving expertly brewed coffee from local roasters like Jersey Shore Roasters and Offshore Coffee. Plus, Pachamama Juice Bar is here with refreshing cold-pressed juices, acai bowls, and smoothies – their turmeric ginger tea is a crowd favorite!

Nancy Burton and Eileen Ricco, our owners, have been a part of the neighborhood since 2013 with In The Garden Flowers & Plants next door. Stop by to see why our customers love shopping here!